Blended green-gray approaches offer a pathway to future global water security
Sustainable development demands reliable water resources, yet traditional water management has broadly failed to avoid environmental degradation and contain infrastructure costs. A recent publication in Global Environmental change by a group of researchers led by Charles Vörösmarty present the global-scale feasibility of combining natural capital with engineering-based (green-gray) approaches to meet water security threats over the 21st century. The required natural capital and green infrastructure are well beyond the scope and scale considered by urban planners and encompass regional to continental-scale environmental assets.
Threats to water resource systems are projected to increase throughout this period, together with a significant expansion in engineering deployments and progressive loss of natural capital. In many parts of the world, strong path dependencies arise from the legacy of prior environmental degradation that constrains future water management to a heavy reliance on engineering-based approaches. Elsewhere, retaining existing stocks of natural capital creates opportunities to employ blended green-gray water infrastructure. By 2050, annual engineering expenditures are projected to triple to $2.3 trillion, invested mainly in developing economies. In contrast, preserving natural capital for threat suppression represents a potential $3.0 trillion in avoided replacement costs by mid-century.
- Water security threats and loss of natural capital rise rapidly across the century.
- Societal response features a major expansion of traditional engineering.
- Contributions of natural capital to water security exceed investments in engineering.
- Degraded ecosystems incur a substantial economic penalty on water resource systems.
- A transformation to sustainable green-gray water infrastructure is globally feasible.
Society pays a premium whenever these nature-based assets are lost, as the engineering costs necessary to achieve an equivalent level of threat management are, on average, twice as expensive. Countries projected to rapidly expand their engineering investments while losing natural capital will be most constrained in realizing green-gray water management. The situation is expected to be most restrictive across the developing world, where the economic, technical, and governance capacities to overcome such challenges remain limited. The results of the study demonstrate that policies that support blended green-gray approaches offer a pathway to future global water security but will require a strategic commitment to preserving natural capital. Absent such stewardship, the costs of water resource infrastructure and services will likely rise substantially and frustrate efforts to attain universal and sustainable water security.
This study emerged from a multi-institutional and interdisciplinary partnership. The maps, affiliated statistics and data sets that represent the tangible products of numerous conceptual and technical discussions held over the span of several years plus earlier work that set the foundation for the current analysis are available here.
Global Environmental Change paper 2021: A green-gray path to global water security and sustainable infrastructure